Hybrid PCBs: Combining Rogers Material with TG170 for Optimal Performance

Customer-anthroized imagery

Hybrid PCBs—using mixed lamination of high-performance Rogers materials and cost-effective TG170 FR4—have emerged as a game-changer for high-frequency electronics. By merging the signal integrity of Rogers with the mechanical strength and affordability of TG170, these PCBs deliver a rare balance of performance, durability, and cost efficiency. Ideal for 5G base stations, radar, and industrial sensor applications, hybrid designs solve a critical challenge: how to achieve high-frequency performance without overspending on materials.

This guide explores the science behind combining Rogers and TG170, design best practices for hybrid stack-ups, and how to overcome manufacturing hurdles—equipping engineers to build PCBs that excel in both high-speed signal transmission and real-world reliability.

Key Takeaways
  1.Hybrid PCBs pairing Rogers and TG170 reduce material costs by 30–40% compared to full Rogers designs while maintaining 90% of the high-frequency performance.
  2.Rogers materials (e.g., RO4350) excel in high-frequency (28GHz+) applications with low dielectric loss (Df = 0.0037) and stable dielectric constant (Dk = 3.48), while TG170 offers mechanical strength (Tg = 170°C) and cost savings for non-critical layers.
  3.Proper stack-up design—placing Rogers in signal-critical layers and TG170 in power/ground layers—maximizes performance while minimizing cost.
  4.Manufacturing challenges like thermal expansion mismatch and lamination bonding are solvable with material selection (matched CTE) and controlled processes (precision lamination).

Why Combine Rogers and TG170?
Rogers and TG170 each bring unique strengths to hybrid PCBs, addressing the limitations of using either material alone:

  a.Rogers materials (e.g., RO4000 series) are engineered for high-frequency performance but come at a premium (3–5x the cost of FR4). They shine in signal-critical layers where low loss and stable Dk are non-negotiable.
  b.TG170 FR4 is a cost-effective, high-Tg laminate (Tg = 170°C) with strong mechanical properties, ideal for power distribution, ground planes, and non-critical signal layers where high-frequency performance is less important.

By combining them, hybrid PCBs leverage Rogers’ electrical performance where it matters most and TG170’s affordability elsewhere—creating a "best of both worlds" solution.

Properties of Rogers and TG170: A Comparison
Understanding the core properties of each material is key to designing effective hybrid PCBs:

Key Strengths of Rogers Material
  a.Low dielectric loss: Df = 0.0037 minimizes signal attenuation in 5G mmWave (28–60GHz) and radar (77GHz) systems.
  b.Stable Dk: Maintains consistent electrical performance across temperature (-40°C to 85°C) and frequency, critical for impedance control.
  c.Moisture resistance: Absorbs <0.1% moisture, ensuring reliability in humid environments (e.g., outdoor 5G small cells).

Key Strengths of TG170
  a.High Tg: Withstands reflow temperatures (260°C) and long-term operation at 130°C, making it suitable for industrial and automotive applications.
  b.Mechanical rigidity: Supports multi-layer designs (12+ layers) without warping, ideal for complex PCBs with power and signal layers.
  c.Cost efficiency: 1/5 the cost of Rogers, reducing total PCB expenses when used in non-critical layers.

Advantages of Hybrid PCBs with Rogers and TG170
Hybrid designs unlock benefits that neither material delivers alone:
1. Balanced Performance and Cost
Example: A 12-layer 5G PCB using Rogers for 2 signal layers (RF paths) and TG170 for 10 power/ground layers costs 35% less than an all-Rogers design while maintaining 92% of the signal integrity.
Use case: Telecom equipment manufacturers report $1.2M annual savings by switching to hybrid designs in 5G base stations.

2. Enhanced Thermal Management
Rogers’ higher thermal conductivity (0.6 W/m·K) dissipates heat from high-power RF amplifiers, while TG170’s rigidity provides structural support for heat sinks.
Result: A hybrid PCB in a radar module runs 15°C cooler than an all-TG170 design, extending component lifespan by 2x.

3. Versatility Across Applications
Hybrid PCBs adapt to diverse needs: Rogers handles high-frequency signals, while TG170 manages power distribution and mechanical stress.
Applications: 5G base stations transceivers, automotive radar, industrial IoT sensors, and satellite communication systems.

Designing Hybrid PCB Stack-Ups: Best Practices
The key to hybrid PCB success lies in strategic layer placement—matching materials to their intended function.
1. Layer Assignment Strategy
Rogers layers: Reserve for high-frequency signal paths (e.g., 28GHz RF traces) and critical impedance-controlled routes (50Ω single-ended, 100Ω differential pairs).
TG170 layers: Use for power planes (3.3V, 5V), ground planes, and low-speed signals (≤1GHz) like control lines.

Example 4-Layer Stack-Up:

1.Top layer: Rogers (RF signal, 28GHz)
2.Inner layer 1: TG170 (ground plane)
3.Inner layer 2: TG170 (power plane)
4.Bottom layer: Rogers (differential pairs, 10Gbps)

2. Impedance Control
Rogers layers: Calculate trace dimensions (width, spacing) to achieve target impedance (e.g., 50Ω) using tools like Polar Si8000. A 50Ω microstrip on Rogers RO4350 (0.2mm dielectric) requires a 0.15mm trace width.
TG170 layers: For low-speed signals, impedance tolerance can relax to ±10% (vs. ±5% for Rogers layers), simplifying design.

3. Thermal and Mechanical Balance
CTE matching: Rogers (Z-axis CTE = 30 ppm/°C) and TG170 (50–60 ppm/°C) have different thermal expansion rates. Mitigate by:
Using thin Rogers layers (0.2–0.3mm) to reduce expansion stress.
Adding "buffer" layers (e.g., TG170 with glass fabric) between them.
Copper weight: Use 2oz copper in TG170 power layers for current handling, and 1oz in Rogers signal layers to minimize loss.

4. Material Compatibility
Prepreg selection: Use epoxy-based prepregs (e.g., Isola FR408) that bond well to both Rogers and TG170. Avoid polyester prepregs, which may delaminate from Rogers.
Surface treatment: Rogers requires plasma cleaning before lamination to improve adhesion to TG170 layers.

Manufacturing Challenges and Solutions
Hybrid PCBs present unique manufacturing hurdles due to material differences, but these are manageable with controlled processes:
1. Lamination Bonding
Challenge: Rogers and TG170 bond poorly with standard prepregs, leading to delamination.
Solution: Use modified epoxy prepregs (e.g., Rogers 4450F) designed for mixed lamination. Apply 300–400 psi pressure and 180°C temperature during lamination to ensure full adhesion.

2. Thermal Expansion Mismatch
Challenge: Differential expansion during reflow can cause warping or layer separation.
Solution:
Limit Rogers layer thickness to ≤30% of total PCB thickness.
Use a symmetrical stack-up (mirroring Rogers and TG170 layers) to balance stress.

3. Drilling and Plating
Challenge: Rogers is softer than TG170, leading to uneven drilling and plating voids.
Solution:
Use diamond-coated drill bits for Rogers layers, with reduced feed rate (50% of standard) to avoid tearing.
Plate vias in two steps: first copper strike (10μm) to seal Rogers, then full plating (25μm) for conductivity.

4. Quality Control
Inspection: Use ultrasonic testing to detect delamination between Rogers and TG170 layers.
Testing: Perform thermal cycling (-40°C to 125°C for 1,000 cycles) to validate mechanical stability.

Applications of Hybrid PCBs
Hybrid PCBs shine in applications requiring both high-frequency performance and cost efficiency:
1. 5G Base Stations
Need: 28GHz mmWave signals (low loss) + power distribution (cost efficiency).
Design: Rogers layers for RF frontends; TG170 for DC power and control circuits.
Result: 30% cost reduction vs. all-Rogers designs with 95% signal integrity.

2. Automotive Radar
Need: 77GHz radar signals (stable Dk) + ruggedness (high Tg).
Design: Rogers for radar transceiver traces; TG170 for power management and CAN bus.
Result: Meets ISO 26262 reliability standards while cutting material costs by 25%.

3. Industrial Sensors
Need: 6GHz IoT signals + resistance to factory temperatures.
Design: Rogers for wireless communication; TG170 for sensor power and processing.
Result: Survives 85°C factory environments with <1% signal loss.

Hybrid vs. Pure Material PCBs: A Performance-Cost Comparison

FAQs
Q: Can hybrid PCBs handle 60GHz+ frequencies?
A: Yes, but reserve Rogers layers for 60GHz paths (e.g., Rogers RT/duroid 5880 with Dk=2.2) and use TG170 for supporting layers. Signal loss at 60GHz is ~5dB/10cm in hybrid designs, vs. 4dB in all-Rogers.

Q: How do I ensure adhesion between Rogers and TG170?
A: Use compatible prepregs (e.g., Rogers 4450F), plasma-treat Rogers surfaces, and control lamination pressure (300–400 psi) and temperature (180°C).

Q: Are hybrid PCBs more complex to design?
A: They require careful stack-up planning, but modern tools (Altium, Cadence) simplify impedance calculations and layer assignment. The cost savings often justify the extra design effort.

Q: What’s the maximum number of layers in a hybrid PCB?
A: 20+ layers are possible with proper stack-up symmetry. Telecom 5G PCBs often use 16-layer hybrid designs (4 Rogers, 12 TG170).

Q: Do hybrid PCBs require special testing?
A: Yes—add ultrasonic inspection for delamination and TDR (Time Domain Reflectometry) to verify impedance in Rogers layers. Thermal cycling tests (-40°C to 125°C) validate mechanical stability.

Conclusion
Hybrid PCBs combining Rogers and TG170 materials represent a smart compromise, delivering high-frequency performance where it matters while leveraging cost-effective TG170 for non-critical layers. By strategically assigning materials to their strengths—Rogers for signal integrity, TG170 for mechanical strength and cost—engineers can build PCBs that meet the demands of 5G, radar, and industrial electronics without overspending.

Success hinges on careful stack-up design, material compatibility, and controlled manufacturing processes. With these in place, hybrid PCBs offer a compelling solution for balancing performance, reliability, and cost in today’s most demanding electronic systems.

As high-frequency applications continue to grow, hybrid lamination will remain a key strategy for engineers seeking to innovate without breaking the budget.